成人小说亚洲一区二区三区,亚洲国产精品一区二区三区,国产精品成人精品久久久,久久综合一区二区三区,精品无码av一区二区,国产一级a毛一级a看免费视频,欧洲uv免费在线区一二区,亚洲国产欧美中日韩成人综合视频,国产熟女一区二区三区五月婷小说,亚洲一区波多野结衣在线

立即打開
12位藝術(shù)家控訴Zara抄襲

12位藝術(shù)家控訴Zara抄襲

Michal Addady 2016-08-07
Zara銷售的一些商品,在某些不太知名的設(shè)計師的粉絲看來,會覺得非常熟悉。

至少有十二位獨立藝術(shù)家控訴該西班牙零售商盜用了自己的設(shè)計,其中一位女性藝術(shù)家圖斯黛伊·貝森(Tuesday Bassen)已正式起訴該公司。這位27歲的插畫師此前曾經(jīng)與Urban Outfitters和耐克等多個品牌有過合作。她指控Zara未經(jīng)允許或未支付報酬,盜用了自己的四幅原創(chuàng)藝術(shù)作品。

今年早些時候,有數(shù)百位粉絲詢問貝森是否正在與Zara合作,還是Zara抄襲了她的作品,那時候她才注意到這個問題。她通過律師聯(lián)系了Zara公司,但得到的答復卻是:

你的代理人聲稱的設(shè)計缺乏獨特性,因此很難判斷大多數(shù)人會如何將這些標志與圖斯黛伊·貝森聯(lián)系在一起。這是我們的觀點,而且我們已經(jīng)充分注意到了你讓我們注意的第三方通知。最后一點請注意,這些通知僅有少量的投訴;考慮到全世界每個月有成百上千萬的用戶在訪問各自的房展(Zara:去年的平均月度訪問量為98,000,000次,Bershka:去年的平均月度訪問量為15,000,000次),通過這些數(shù)據(jù)可以非常清晰地看透這些為數(shù)不多的通知。

貝森對此的理解是,他們拒絕了自己的版權(quán)主張,原因是她是一個小藝術(shù)家,而Zara及其姊妹品牌則擁有成百上千萬的客戶。她對《財富》雜志(Fortune)表示:“這對藝術(shù)家的生活有巨大的影響。我要以此為生,但他們卻故意盜用我的作品,稀釋我的品牌?!?/p>

另外一位聲稱作品被盜用的設(shè)計師亞當·庫爾茨(Adam Kurtz),制作了一幅圖,將Zara的商品與獨立藝術(shù)家的作品進行了對比。大圖代表小設(shè)計師們的原創(chuàng)藝術(shù)作品,右上角的圖片則是Zara涉嫌抄襲的設(shè)計。

While at least a dozen indie artists are claiming that the Spanish retailer has stolen their designs, one woman in particular, Tuesday Bassen, has filed an official complaint with the company. The 27-year-old illustrator, who has previously worked with brands like Urban Outfitters and?Nike, has accused Zara of appropriating four pieces of her original artwork without permission or compensation.

Bassen became aware of the issue early this year when hundreds of her fans reached out to her asking whether she was collaborating with Zara or if the company had plagiarized her work. When she got in touch with the company through a lawyer, they responded with the following:

The lack of distinctiveness of your client’s purported designs makes it very hard to see how a significant part of the population anywhere would associate the signs with Tuesday Bassen. This is our firm view, and being fully aware of the 3rd party notifications that you have brought to our attention. In this last regard, please note that such notifications amount to a handful of complaints only; when it is borne in mind that millions of users worldwide visit the respective websites monthly (Zara: 98,000.000 average monthly visits last year, Bershka: 15.000.000 average monthly visits last year), the figures clearly put those few notifications into sharp perspective.

Bassen interpreted this to mean that they have rejected her copyright claims because she is a small artist while Zara and its sister brands have millions of customers. “It has an awful impact on the livelihood of an artist,” she told?Fortune. “This is how I support myself, and they are diluting my brand by literally stealing from me.”

Adam Kurtz, another designer whose work has allegedly been copied, produced a graphic comparing Zara’s products to those of indie artists. The larger photos show original artwork by the smaller designers, while the pictures in the upper right hand corners show Zara’s supposed recreations.

貝森也制作了一幅圖,將自己原創(chuàng)的四個設(shè)計,與Zara的相關(guān)產(chǎn)品進行了對比。

Bassen also created a graphic showing four of her original designs next to the Zara products in question.

威利·瑞恩的律師詹姆斯·華萊士認為,由于信息有限,貝森的主張是“沒有根據(jù)的?!彼J為,這些短語和形狀屬于公有領(lǐng)域,這些設(shè)計的相似度不足以支持版權(quán)侵犯主張。

但弗羅斯特·布朗·托德的律師梅麗莎·科恩卻并不同意。她告訴《財富》雜志:“單獨來看,我能明白為什么Zara會聲稱它們沒有獨特性。但我認為你需要換一個角度,你要將橡皮和文字看成一個整體,包括顏色、角度等。”

雖然某些形狀或短語不會受到保護,但這些元素的組合卻可以讓貝森的訴求更有可信度。而且考慮到貝森指控Zara抄襲了一系列設(shè)計而不是一款設(shè)計,這將讓她對該零售商的指控更有說服力。

貝森對《財富》雜志表示,她計劃繼續(xù)起訴,并補充道:“我希望起訴的結(jié)果之一是,讓更多人意識到這種情況經(jīng)常發(fā)生,但很少有藝術(shù)家能夠承擔維護權(quán)利的成本?!?

《財富》雜志聯(lián)系了Zara母公司Inditex,尋求其對此事的意見。他們的回復是:

Inditex對所有藝術(shù)家和設(shè)計師的創(chuàng)造力,懷有深深的敬意,并且對于所有有關(guān)第三方知識產(chǎn)權(quán)的主張都會認真對待。最近,圖斯黛伊·貝森的律師聯(lián)系了Inditex,稱發(fā)現(xiàn)在外部采購的部分徽章以及集團店鋪內(nèi)的服裝上使用了貝森的插畫設(shè)計。公司立即對此事展開了調(diào)查,并將部分物品暫停銷售。Inditex的法律團隊也盡快與圖斯黛伊·貝森的律師取得了聯(lián)系,澄清和解決了相關(guān)問題。(財富中文網(wǎng))

作者:Michal Addady

譯者:劉進龍/汪皓

James Wallace, attorney with Wiley Rein, says that based on this limited information Bassen’s claims are “baseless.” He argues that certain phrases and shapes are?public domain, and the designs simply aren’t similar enough to claim?copyrightinfringement.

Melissa Kern, an attorney at Frost Brown Todd, disagrees. “Individually looking at them, I could see where?Zara?could take the position that they’re not distinctive,” she told?Fortune. “But I think you could take a contrary position if you look at the eraser with the text as a whole, the coloring, angle.”

While certain shapes or phrases can’t be protected, it’s the combination of all those components that give Bassen’s claims credibility. And considering the fact that she’s accusing Zara of copying a collection of pieces and not just one design, a case against the retailer could be that much stronger.

Bassen told?Fortune?that she plans to pursue this case further, adding, “I hope that one outcome is that I can raise awareness for how often this happens and how few artists can actually afford to pursue it.”

Fortune?reached out to Inditex, Zara’s parent company, for a comment, and they responded with the following:

Inditex has the utmost respect for the individual creativity of all artists and designers and takes all claims concerning third party intellectual property rights very seriously.?Inditex was recently contacted by Tuesday Bassen’s lawyers who noted the use of illustrations in some badges sourced externally and on clothes in its Group stores. The Company immediately opened an investigation into the matter and suspended the relevant items from sale. Inditex’s legal team is also in contact with Tuesday Bassen’s lawyers to clarify and resolve the situation as swiftly as possible.

掃描二維碼下載財富APP
精品香蕉久久久午夜福利| 青青久在线视频免费观看| 黑人无码精品又粗又大又长| 日本熟妇色熟妇在线视频播放| 国产午夜福利不卡在线观看| 午夜福利免费区在线观看手机| 久久久五月天亚洲天堂中文字幕在线观看| av电影在线观看不卡的| 国产AV无码专区亚洲AWWW| 亚洲精品国产成人片在线观看一区二区三区日韩| 日韩一区二区三区视频| 亚洲国产成人精品无码区在线观看| 久久永久免费人妻精品直播| 成人免费毛片在线观看| 成熟丰满熟妇高潮XXXXX| 我要看一级大黄毛片| 免费人成在线观看网站品爱网日本| 丰满少妇熟女高潮流白浆| 日韩欧美一区二区精品久久第一页| 国产精品久久欧美久久一区| 国产日韩欧美成人综合电影在线观看| 久久亚洲色www成人欧美| 亚洲VA在线VA天堂XXXX| 久久人妻夜夜做天天爽| 成人午夜免费在线观看| 91精品啪在线观看国产电影| 亚洲综合色在线观看一区二区三区| 亚洲国产成人精品无码区宅男| 无码精品黑人一区二区三区| 成人AV鲁丝片一区二区免费| 国产精品高清一区二区三区| 农村老熟妇乱子伦视频| 亚洲A∨精品一区二区三区| 久久久精品国产亚洲综合久久久国产中文字幕免费| 性刺激的欧美三级视频中文字幕| 久久人人爽人人爽人人片AV麻烦| 国产精品色视频ⅩXXX| 亚洲精品美女久久久久网站| 亚洲第一狠人99久久综合网站 | 中文字幕在线观看一区| 亚洲国产AV玩弄放荡人妇|