隨著民眾呼吁美國總統(tǒng)喬·拜登加大向富人的征稅力度,加密貨幣百萬富翁正在中美洲建立自己的免稅天堂。
在拉丁美洲創(chuàng)建由加密貨幣支持的小型烏托邦的吸引力在于可以免于稅收和監(jiān)管。走在這一運(yùn)動最前沿的企業(yè)是自由私人城市基金會(Free Private Cities Foundation),該公司倡導(dǎo)的理念是“自愿的、以契約為基礎(chǔ)的社會”,并支持全球私人城市發(fā)展。它們的口號是“治理的未來是私有的”。
據(jù)《麻省理工學(xué)院科技評論》(MIT Tech Review)報道,由泰特斯·格貝爾博士創(chuàng)立的自由私人城市基金會鼓勵薩爾瓦多政府將其即將建立的比特幣城(Bitcoin City)交到企業(yè)手中,并允許由私營部門治理。
薩爾瓦多計劃在火山底部建立一座由地?zé)狎?qū)動的比特幣城,這只是該國向世界各個國家推銷的免稅經(jīng)濟(jì)特區(qū)的冰山一角。
向薩爾瓦多以外的地區(qū)擴(kuò)張
在巴西,格貝爾的公司也提出了建立由公司監(jiān)管的私有化城市的想法,該公司希望創(chuàng)建多個國際“繁榮區(qū)”。此外,自由私人城市基金會已經(jīng)將目光投向洪都拉斯。
據(jù)Peace Brigades International Honduras稱,在洪都拉斯于2013年修訂憲法允許公司治理特區(qū)后,洪都拉斯有三個主要的經(jīng)濟(jì)發(fā)展和就業(yè)區(qū)(Zones of Economic Development and Employment,以下簡稱ZEDE),它們分別稱為Ciudad Morazán、Orquídea和Próspera。引用網(wǎng)站Nacla.org的話說,ZEDE是由公司獨(dú)立治理的經(jīng)濟(jì)區(qū),通常被稱為“自由私人城市”。
Web3行業(yè)的法律咨詢公司ByteBao的創(chuàng)始人及首席執(zhí)行官賈米利亞·格里爾對ZEDE將如何作為私人城市運(yùn)作持合理懷疑態(tài)度。
他在接受《財富》雜志采訪時說:“就建設(shè)城市而言,這有點(diǎn)像政治、經(jīng)濟(jì)和真正的物理基礎(chǔ)設(shè)施之間的完美風(fēng)暴。問題是:如何實(shí)現(xiàn)這些方面的治理?”
那么,ZEDE由私人治理的話意味著什么?
私人治理就是這個意思。根據(jù)美國國家律師協(xié)會(National Lawyers Guild)代表團(tuán)對洪都拉斯 ZEDE 的調(diào)查報告,私有化城邦“獨(dú)立于洪都拉斯國家的法律、行政和社會體系”。
據(jù)Federal News Network報道,這意味著ZEDE無需繳納進(jìn)出口稅,能夠自由建立自己的政府、學(xué)校、法院和社會保障體系。由于完全缺乏監(jiān)管,一些批評者擔(dān)心ZEDE可能成為犯罪活動的私人避風(fēng)港。
格里爾質(zhì)疑道:“如果你要在一個國家建立這樣一座城市,那么你與該國達(dá)成的該特定區(qū)域無需納稅的協(xié)議是什么?主權(quán)國家必須放棄權(quán)利,才可以建立它們所提議的這種免稅特區(qū)?!?/p>
ZEDE如何造福當(dāng)?shù)厝耍?/strong>
即使ZEDE將政治主權(quán)拱手讓給外國公司,但是從自由私人城市基金會的角度來看,它們也是在“世界上最暴力的國家之一”創(chuàng)造安全避難所。根據(jù)Statista的數(shù)據(jù),2021年,洪都拉斯的兇殺案僅次于薩爾瓦多,而且該國也是世界上婦女謀殺率最高的國家。
自由私人城市基金會于今年3月15日宣布它們正在開發(fā)私人城市Morazán,其網(wǎng)站將Morazán描述為“藍(lán)領(lǐng)ZEDE”,居民在Morazán能夠避免困擾洪都拉斯人日常生活的結(jié)構(gòu)性問題,例如“過度暴力”。此外,Morazán將有可以容納9000名居民的住宅區(qū)、商業(yè)空間、學(xué)校、公園和“工業(yè)區(qū)”。
根據(jù)3月的聲明,“Morazán是一個旨在鼓勵創(chuàng)業(yè)的社區(qū);第一批商業(yè)租戶已經(jīng)入駐。租戶選擇簽訂自愿合同,合同明確規(guī)定了他們的權(quán)利和責(zé)任,這樣他們就能夠確保規(guī)則不會改變?!?/p>
為了換取在更安全的社區(qū)生活的機(jī)會,ZEDE公民與私營公司簽訂合同,在理想情況下,他們有一個安全避難所,可以遠(yuǎn)離高犯罪率。
當(dāng)?shù)厝丝赡軙w移
雖然ZEDE創(chuàng)立者兜售能夠提高當(dāng)?shù)厝松钏降南敕?,但其好處可能被高估了。盡管ZEDE被推銷為洪都拉斯的就業(yè)來源——該國超過60%的人生活在貧困中——但當(dāng)在洪都拉斯的羅阿坦島建造該國三個主要ZEDE之一Próspera時,大部分建筑工作被外包,而不是提供給當(dāng)?shù)氐暮槎祭谷恕?/p>
引用經(jīng)濟(jì)學(xué)家卡洛斯·烏爾比佐·索利斯的話說,ZEDE的稅收優(yōu)惠非但不會給當(dāng)?shù)貛矸睒s,反而會擴(kuò)大洪都拉斯本已嚴(yán)重的收入不平等,這只會讓少數(shù)人受益。
由于政府接受外國投資來創(chuàng)建ZEDE,當(dāng)?shù)厝酥荒苎郾牨牭乜粗厩终妓麄兊耐恋?。批評人士指出,為ZEDE建設(shè)而規(guī)劃的區(qū)域是加里富納地區(qū)的祖?zhèn)魍恋?,該地區(qū)的原住民已經(jīng)在這片土地上生活了數(shù)千年之久。因此,ZEDE建設(shè)將導(dǎo)致當(dāng)?shù)鼐用竦拇笠?guī)模遷移。
許多洪都拉斯公民反對ZEDE的存在,他們的理由是由此導(dǎo)致的出售私人土地以及貧困率上升等問題。由于ZEDE是獨(dú)立的司法管轄區(qū),有自己的法律,因此,它們在刑事司法系統(tǒng)中擁有完全的自主權(quán)。
Crypto Cannabis Club的首席執(zhí)行官瑞恩·亨特告訴《財富》雜志:“我們看到的是一個技術(shù)創(chuàng)新快速發(fā)展的新時代。其中一些創(chuàng)新是可持續(xù)的,而其他一些創(chuàng)新卻是失敗的,但這些失敗的創(chuàng)新將會提供有價值的見解,從而促進(jìn)進(jìn)一步增長。我認(rèn)為我們現(xiàn)在說加密貨幣城市還為時過早,但我確實(shí)喜歡這一運(yùn)動所代表的創(chuàng)業(yè)精神和創(chuàng)新?!保ㄘ敻恢形木W(wǎng))
譯者:ZHY
隨著民眾呼吁美國總統(tǒng)喬·拜登加大向富人的征稅力度,加密貨幣百萬富翁正在中美洲建立自己的免稅天堂。
在拉丁美洲創(chuàng)建由加密貨幣支持的小型烏托邦的吸引力在于可以免于稅收和監(jiān)管。走在這一運(yùn)動最前沿的企業(yè)是自由私人城市基金會(Free Private Cities Foundation),該公司倡導(dǎo)的理念是“自愿的、以契約為基礎(chǔ)的社會”,并支持全球私人城市發(fā)展。它們的口號是“治理的未來是私有的”。
據(jù)《麻省理工學(xué)院科技評論》(MIT Tech Review)報道,由泰特斯·格貝爾博士創(chuàng)立的自由私人城市基金會鼓勵薩爾瓦多政府將其即將建立的比特幣城(Bitcoin City)交到企業(yè)手中,并允許由私營部門治理。
薩爾瓦多計劃在火山底部建立一座由地?zé)狎?qū)動的比特幣城,這只是該國向世界各個國家推銷的免稅經(jīng)濟(jì)特區(qū)的冰山一角。
向薩爾瓦多以外的地區(qū)擴(kuò)張
在巴西,格貝爾的公司也提出了建立由公司監(jiān)管的私有化城市的想法,該公司希望創(chuàng)建多個國際“繁榮區(qū)”。此外,自由私人城市基金會已經(jīng)將目光投向洪都拉斯。
據(jù)Peace Brigades International Honduras稱,在洪都拉斯于2013年修訂憲法允許公司治理特區(qū)后,洪都拉斯有三個主要的經(jīng)濟(jì)發(fā)展和就業(yè)區(qū)(Zones of Economic Development and Employment,以下簡稱ZEDE),它們分別稱為Ciudad Morazán、Orquídea和Próspera。引用網(wǎng)站Nacla.org的話說,ZEDE是由公司獨(dú)立治理的經(jīng)濟(jì)區(qū),通常被稱為“自由私人城市”。
Web3行業(yè)的法律咨詢公司ByteBao的創(chuàng)始人及首席執(zhí)行官賈米利亞·格里爾對ZEDE將如何作為私人城市運(yùn)作持合理懷疑態(tài)度。
他在接受《財富》雜志采訪時說:“就建設(shè)城市而言,這有點(diǎn)像政治、經(jīng)濟(jì)和真正的物理基礎(chǔ)設(shè)施之間的完美風(fēng)暴。問題是:如何實(shí)現(xiàn)這些方面的治理?”
那么,ZEDE由私人治理的話意味著什么?
私人治理就是這個意思。根據(jù)美國國家律師協(xié)會(National Lawyers Guild)代表團(tuán)對洪都拉斯 ZEDE 的調(diào)查報告,私有化城邦“獨(dú)立于洪都拉斯國家的法律、行政和社會體系”。
據(jù)Federal News Network報道,這意味著ZEDE無需繳納進(jìn)出口稅,能夠自由建立自己的政府、學(xué)校、法院和社會保障體系。由于完全缺乏監(jiān)管,一些批評者擔(dān)心ZEDE可能成為犯罪活動的私人避風(fēng)港。
格里爾質(zhì)疑道:“如果你要在一個國家建立這樣一座城市,那么你與該國達(dá)成的該特定區(qū)域無需納稅的協(xié)議是什么?主權(quán)國家必須放棄權(quán)利,才可以建立它們所提議的這種免稅特區(qū)?!?/p>
ZEDE如何造福當(dāng)?shù)厝耍?/strong>
即使ZEDE將政治主權(quán)拱手讓給外國公司,但是從自由私人城市基金會的角度來看,它們也是在“世界上最暴力的國家之一”創(chuàng)造安全避難所。根據(jù)Statista的數(shù)據(jù),2021年,洪都拉斯的兇殺案僅次于薩爾瓦多,而且該國也是世界上婦女謀殺率最高的國家。
自由私人城市基金會于今年3月15日宣布它們正在開發(fā)私人城市Morazán,其網(wǎng)站將Morazán描述為“藍(lán)領(lǐng)ZEDE”,居民在Morazán能夠避免困擾洪都拉斯人日常生活的結(jié)構(gòu)性問題,例如“過度暴力”。此外,Morazán將有可以容納9000名居民的住宅區(qū)、商業(yè)空間、學(xué)校、公園和“工業(yè)區(qū)”。
根據(jù)3月的聲明,“Morazán是一個旨在鼓勵創(chuàng)業(yè)的社區(qū);第一批商業(yè)租戶已經(jīng)入駐。租戶選擇簽訂自愿合同,合同明確規(guī)定了他們的權(quán)利和責(zé)任,這樣他們就能夠確保規(guī)則不會改變。”
為了換取在更安全的社區(qū)生活的機(jī)會,ZEDE公民與私營公司簽訂合同,在理想情況下,他們有一個安全避難所,可以遠(yuǎn)離高犯罪率。
當(dāng)?shù)厝丝赡軙w移
雖然ZEDE創(chuàng)立者兜售能夠提高當(dāng)?shù)厝松钏降南敕?,但其好處可能被高估了。盡管ZEDE被推銷為洪都拉斯的就業(yè)來源——該國超過60%的人生活在貧困中——但當(dāng)在洪都拉斯的羅阿坦島建造該國三個主要ZEDE之一Próspera時,大部分建筑工作被外包,而不是提供給當(dāng)?shù)氐暮槎祭谷恕?/p>
引用經(jīng)濟(jì)學(xué)家卡洛斯·烏爾比佐·索利斯的話說,ZEDE的稅收優(yōu)惠非但不會給當(dāng)?shù)貛矸睒s,反而會擴(kuò)大洪都拉斯本已嚴(yán)重的收入不平等,這只會讓少數(shù)人受益。
由于政府接受外國投資來創(chuàng)建ZEDE,當(dāng)?shù)厝酥荒苎郾牨牭乜粗厩终妓麄兊耐恋?。批評人士指出,為ZEDE建設(shè)而規(guī)劃的區(qū)域是加里富納地區(qū)的祖?zhèn)魍恋?,該地區(qū)的原住民已經(jīng)在這片土地上生活了數(shù)千年之久。因此,ZEDE建設(shè)將導(dǎo)致當(dāng)?shù)鼐用竦拇笠?guī)模遷移。
許多洪都拉斯公民反對ZEDE的存在,他們的理由是由此導(dǎo)致的出售私人土地以及貧困率上升等問題。由于ZEDE是獨(dú)立的司法管轄區(qū),有自己的法律,因此,它們在刑事司法系統(tǒng)中擁有完全的自主權(quán)。
Crypto Cannabis Club的首席執(zhí)行官瑞恩·亨特告訴《財富》雜志:“我們看到的是一個技術(shù)創(chuàng)新快速發(fā)展的新時代。其中一些創(chuàng)新是可持續(xù)的,而其他一些創(chuàng)新卻是失敗的,但這些失敗的創(chuàng)新將會提供有價值的見解,從而促進(jìn)進(jìn)一步增長。我認(rèn)為我們現(xiàn)在說加密貨幣城市還為時過早,但我確實(shí)喜歡這一運(yùn)動所代表的創(chuàng)業(yè)精神和創(chuàng)新?!保ㄘ敻恢形木W(wǎng))
譯者:ZHY
As the nation calls for President Joe Biden to ramp up taxes on the wealthy, crypto millionaires are creating their own tax-free havens in Central America.
The draw of creating small crypto-backed utopias in Latin America is the freedom from both taxes and regulations. At the forefront of this movement is the Free Private Cities Foundation, a company that promotes the idea of “voluntary, contract based societies,” and supports the development of private cities all over the globe. Their slogan is “the future of governance is private.”
Founded by Dr. Titus Gebel, the Free Private Cities Foundation has encouraged the Salvadoran government to place its impending Bitcoin City in corporate hands, allowing the city to be governed by the private sector, as reported by MIT Tech Review.
El Salvador’s plan for a geothermally powered Bitcoin city at the base of a volcano is just the tip of the iceberg for special tax-free economic zones that are being pitched to various countries abroad.
Expanding outside El Salvador
In Brazil, the idea of privatized cities that would be overseen by corporations is also being floated around by Gebel’s company, which hopes to create multiple international “prosperity zones.” In addition, the Free Private Cities Foundation has set its sights on Honduras.
Following an amendment to their constitution in 2013 that allowed special zones managed by companies, Honduras has three main ZEDEs—Zones of Economic Development and Employment—called Ciudad Morazán, Orquídea and Próspera, according to the Peace Brigades International Honduras. ZEDEs are economic zones that are independently governed by corporations and are commonly referred to as “free private cities,” citing Nacla.org.
Jamilia Grier, founder and CEO of ByteBao, a legal consulting firm in the Web3 industry, has a healthy level of skepticism on how the ZEDEs would function as private cities.
“This is sort of like the perfect storm between political, economic, and really just your physical infrastructure as far as building a city. The question is: how are those governed?” Grier said in an interview with Fortune.
So what does it mean for a ZEDE to be privately governed?
Private governance means just that. The privatized city-states “exist independently from the legal, administrative and social systems of the Honduran state,” according to a report from the National Lawyers Guild (NLG) Delegation Investigation of ZEDEs in Honduras.
This means that the ZEDEs don’t have to pay import or export taxes and are free to set up their own forms of governments, schools, courts, and social security systems, as reported by the Federal News Network. With such a complete lack of regulation, some critics fear that ZEDEs could become private havens for criminal activity.
“If you were to create one of these cities within a country, what is the agreement that you have with the country that this particular area is not subject to tax?” Grier questioned. “There would have to be a relinquishing of rights from the sovereign nation to be able to create this particular tax-free zone that they're proposing.”
How do ZEDEs benefit local people?
Even if ZEDEs surrender political sovereignty to foreign corporations, from the perspective of the Free Private Cities Foundation, they are creating safe havens in “one of the most violent countries in the world.” Last year, Honduras was second only to El Salvador in homicides, according to Statista and the country also has the highest femicide rate in the world.
The Free Private Cities Foundation announced on March 15 the ongoing development of their private city, Morazán, which the website described as a “blue collar ZEDE,” where residents can avoid the structural issues that plague Hondurans in everyday life such as “exorbitant violence.” Additionally, Morazán will have housing zones that can house 9,000 residents, commercial spaces, schools, parks and “an industrial zone.”
“Morazán is a community designed to encourage entrepreneurship; the first commercial tenants have already arrived,” according to the March statement. “The tenants choose to enter voluntary contracts that spell out their rights and responsibilities so they can be sure the rules won’t be changed on them.”
In exchange for living in safer communities, citizens of ZEDEs enter into contracts with the private corporations and ideally speaking, have a secure refuge from high crime rates.
Possible displacement of locals
While the creators of ZEDEs tout ideas about higher standards of living for the locals, the benefits may be overestimated. Despite ZEDEs being marketed as sources of employment in Honduras—where over 60% of the country lives in poverty—when one of the country’s three main ZEDEs, Próspera, was built on Honduran island of Roatán, the majority of those construction jobs were outsourced rather than being offered to the native Hondurans.
Far from bringing prosperity to the local citizens, the ZEDEs’ tax benefits will widen Honduras’ already stark income inequality and benefit only a select few, citing economist Carlos Urbizo Solis.
As the government accepts foreign investments for the creation of ZEDEs, locals watch as corporations encroach upon their lands. Critics have pointed out that the areas mapped out for ZEDE construction are ancestral lands in the Garifuna region which has been inhabited by the indigenous people for thousands of years. As a result, the construction of ZEDEs would lead to the mass displacement of the native population.
Many of the citizens of Honduras oppose the existence of ZEDEs, citing issues such as the sale of private territories and lands, and an increase in poverty rates. And because ZEDEs are independent jurisdictions with their own laws, they hold complete autonomy in the criminal justice system.
“We are seeing a new era of rapid technological innovation,” Ryan Hunter, CEO of Crypto Cannabis Club told Fortune. “Some of these innovations will be sustainable and some will be unsuccessful, but will provide valuable insights to enable further growth. I think crypto cities are too early to tell, but I do love the entrepreneurial spirit and innovation this movement represents.”